By camel_landy - 10 Jan 2009
I've been following various threads about the canceling of the G4, then I started reading the thread on disco3.co.uk.
http://www.disco3.co.uk/forum/topic29281.html
One of the posts there raised an interesting point which I think might be worth discussing...
Basically, how collectable would these cars be? After all, they're standard cars, fitted with a set of standard accessories and have been sat around waiting for an event that isn't going to happen. By the time they're released, they will probably getting on for 12mths and any history will be limited to those used on selections.
So, other than being a stunning looking car... Would this be enough to maintain a 'collectable' status as an event car or are they in the same league as say one of the G4 LE cars??
/DISCUSS ON :D
M
PS... Don't get me wrong, I thnk the G4 D3 with the TDV6 is a stonking car. :cool:
|
By CraigS-L - 10 Jan 2009
If the G4 is cancelled for good (anyone know?) then I think there will be an 'interest' value - the event that never was - but the premium would be less than for the 03 or 06 cars.If it is restarted, then I think there will be very little premium at all. However in the current market, I am not sure any G4's really have a premium at all, unlike the camels, so we are all best to hang on to them or let them go to a fellow enthusiast if we have had enough - my thoughts are I will never get anything significant back on mine so it is currently in the 'keep it forever' category.
|
By camel_landy - 11 Jan 2009
Well... I suppose only time will tell what happens with G4.
I understand what you're saying about the cars... How much of a difference do you think the diesel engines will make on these cars??
I'm in two minds... The V8s have the history but the TDV6s are more useable for the like of a daily driver.
M
|
By The OC (Augusto) - 11 Jan 2009
"The V8s have the history but the TDV6s are more useable for the like of a daily driver.
M[/quote]
I'm with you...and if the G4 Challenge really cease to exist think will be hard to keep value as much as Camel given limited life...but as said time will tell
I will enjoy my Orange beauty as mush as I can...
|
By willowkis - 12 Jan 2009
I feel I must take issue with the comment about the popularity of the G4 over Camel. Irrespective of whether a further event takes place the history and visual impact of the G4 cars will ALWAYS create interest.Given the obvious age advantage of the G4 vehicles and the significantly more attractive colour scheme as well as the vehicle model range it is obvious that the G4 vehicles will continue to attract attention and admiration wherever they go! G4 LIVES ON ...... :P:P:P Kim ;)
|
By CraigS-L - 12 Jan 2009
Don't disagree Kim, but the question was ' how collectable.... ' which roughly translates to ' is there a premium to their value... '.Yes they are noticeable, and they always get admiring/weird/aggressive reaction from other users, and often cause conversations that may never have otherwise happened, however I fear that the (current) perceived value of camel's may not transfer for while to our fleet.
|
By camel_landy - 12 Jan 2009
willowkis (1/12/2009) Ifeel I must take issue with the comment about the popularity of the G4 over Camel. Irrespective of whether a further event takes place the history and visual impact of the G4 cars will ALWAYS create interest.
Careful... That's two different things.
Just because something looks stunning, doesn't mean it's popular. it took a LONG time before Camel got the following it has...
Giventhe obvious age advantage of the G4 vehicles and the significantly more attractive colour scheme as well as the vehicle model range it is obvious that the G4 vehicles will continue to attract attention and admiration wherever they go!
Actually, this could probably be a discussion point in its own right...
Is it obvious? Do we just sit back & let the 'fame & attention' come to us?? What do we reckon long term??? After 6mths, is it just going to be old news? Personally, this is where I think the club comes into its own...
But more specifically, what about the '09 vehicles?
* The '03 vehicles were beset with various 'issues'.
* The '06 vehicles scared people off being V8 petrol.
Remember that, other than the stickers, everything on the '09 vehicles is available 'off-the-shelf'. However, will the diesel engines raise the popularity?
M
|
By aedwar57 - 12 Jan 2009
I think the 03/06 vehicles will over time (due to thier rarity) have a 'value', but it is a small market place.The 09 vehicles will be of less interest to the market place in regards to the history of the vehicle - but being diesel, will still have a demand.. Lets hope Land Rover will in the future return to the 'spirit of adventure' although the format may have to change. I would only sell mine if I can get another.... Regards,
|
By The OC (Augusto) - 12 Jan 2009
Oil is now below $40, paid 80p the other day for petrol...at least that is good at the moment, will enjoy my D3 as much as I can!! But agree with the comment that the club should continue to promote the legacy and interest in the cars/ event.
|
By marco g4 - 12 Jan 2009
I dont think it put every one off with the cars being v8 not diesel, I dont think i would of bought it if it was a diesel as it was the td6 engine thats underpowered at the time, and it depends if you bought it for day to day use or just for a laugh.Mark 06 G4 FFRR, V8 90
|
By Emon - 12 Jan 2009
Some interesting points raised here and oft discussed with any collectables, at the end there is little science in it. We all probably make up our own minds, I would like to get a 09 D3 as well as keeping the beloved 03 Defender - if luck and financial fate allow it. Being a hobbyist dealer, I asked my wife just how she deals with 'collectables' to add a bit of science into it, she said she makes an educated guess on the following attributes: 1. Iconic design typifying a time or period; 2. Rarity or potential rarity; 3. Condition; 4. Practical value, but this is very much up to the individual; 5. Pedigree; 6. Time;
|
By camel_landy - 13 Jan 2009
marco g4 range rover (1/12/2009) I dont think it put every one off with the cars being v8 not diesel...
That's not what I said though.
It obviously didn't put everyone off, otherwise we'd never have a club but look at the 'Enthusiast' market and what has happened in the past.
Firstly, 'Enthusiasts'. For most enthusiasts, to justify the purchase a G4 vehicle, they would also look to using it as a daily driver. A V8 petrol becomes an expensive proposition... Just look at the Range Rover market, someone purchasing a second hand vehicle is usually after a diesel rather than petrol and so the diesels retain their value better.
Not that I'm a betting man but I'd almost put money on the fact the if the '06 G4 RRS was a TDV6, those cars wouldn't be sitting on AutoTrader right now! I'd also probably bet that PJB would still have his G4 RRS rather than having to change to a TDV6.
ISTR that there was someone else on the forum who was forced to change their G4 Disco 3 when their company found out it was a V8 petrol...
Don't get me wrong, I love my V8s, I'm a 'Petrolhead' & I've driven them for years :cool: but I do also realise that some people have problems with the fuel consumption.
However, I also think that this is where the '09 vehicles will make up for their lack of 'history'...
M
|
By CraigS-L - 13 Jan 2009
ISTR that there was someone else on the forum who was forced to change their G4 Disco 3 when their company found out it was a V8 petrol... CFB on disco3.co.uk But then he has single handedly tries to keep LR production lines moving, he is on about his 5th D3 and has had Puma Defenders and 2 FL2's in the last couple of years ........(running joke on the other forum)
|
By martin bisby - 13 Jan 2009
craig you beat me to that reply, yes CFB is subject to some rather pointed banter over there,however my two pennyworth is that LR might sub the 09 fleet to LRE, however that would not be very smart as LRE exist to prove to ordinary purchasers that their vehicle is as capable as the silverfleet and it would be rather daunting for the "average" punter to find a tricked up all bells and whistles exped vehicle sitting there waiting to be mastered in a free half day slot,(LRE instructors please dont flame me i do know of the other good work you do) the question of would they command a premium, actully no they wouldnt 1. no history (03 & 06 and the camel's for a long number of events) 2. as mark says the add on stuff is available ex stock, paint? maybe 3. only the recce vehicles have done something and would not engineering be looking at the FL2 to see how its stood up. but whats one recce in comparison to the 03 & 06 recce vehicles 4. you wouldnt buy one just because its diesel(as in 2 above) as i am sure that LR wont sell too cheaply after all most only have delivery milage and not like the 03's with 3-4K on the clocks. the way forward in my opinion is for LR TO RELEASE ALL THE 03 STOCK AND LET THE CLUB PROMOTE THE g4 GHALLENGE CONCEPT regards martin
|
By Paul Burt - 13 Jan 2009
camel_landy (1/13/2009)
marco g4 range rover (1/12/2009) I dont think it put every one off with the cars being v8 not diesel...That's not what I said though. It obviously didn't put everyone off, otherwise we'd never have a club but look at the 'Enthusiast' market and what has happened in the past. Firstly, 'Enthusiasts'. For most enthusiasts, to justify the purchase a G4 vehicle, they would also look to using it as a daily driver. A V8 petrol becomes an expensive proposition... Just look at the Range Rover market, someone purchasing a second hand vehicle is usually after a diesel rather than petrol and so the diesels retain their value better. Not that I'm a betting man but I'd almost put money on the fact the if the '06 G4 RRS was a TDV6, those cars wouldn't be sitting on AutoTrader right now! I'd also probably bet that PJB would still have his G4 RRS rather than having to change to a TDV6. ISTR that there was someone else on the forum who was forced to change their G4 Disco 3 when their company found out it was a V8 petrol... Don't get me wrong, I love my V8s, I'm a 'Petrolhead' & I've driven them for years :cool: but I do also realise that some people have problems with the fuel consumption. However, I also think that this is where the '09 vehicles will make up for their lack of 'history'... M You are right, if my RRS had been a diesel I would still have it - At least I still see it everyday but sadly do not own it - and if the 09 vehicles come out at a sensible price, ie I'm expecting them to be discounted on a standard spec and colour car, then I for one will try to buy one. Why do I think they will be discounted - The land rover main dealers were initially very uninterested in what came out so they bid very low on the 2003/2006 vehicles. Suddenly a market developed & they all jumped in, but many had difficulty selling them as it was often the specialists who were better placed to sell for the higher prices. - This time the event has been scrapped they never took part in an event so the genuine event factor is gone, the additional equipment makes very little difference except to a sad geek like me, they will have a novelty factor and that sadly is probably all, and finally the 4x4 market has dropped off a cliff and I cannot see many dealers wanting to take a punt on what might become a vehicle that is very difficult to sell - They are happy for us to lose money on cars but they are not going to bid very high on cars that in a normal spec lose £2k a month. - they will be looking to sell within 12 weeks, so will buy accordingly, they are in business to make a profit and as many have had their fingers burnt recently I cannot see them offering good money. - At least this is what I'm hoping for ! If we all talk the market down I might get my G4 TDV8.;) The only fly in the ointment is my wife drives my car all the time and I'm driving her mini, even cheaper to run, and I'm not sure she will be so keen on another tango. Regards
|
By xtc - 13 Jan 2009
There were only 7 RRS built for the '09 event so I can see a bit of a punch-up coming on :D One of those has been in Mongolia for most of '08 so has some history to it.... I would imagine 2 or 3 will make their way to LRE franchises leaving only a few for sale.
|
By Superlightr - 14 Jan 2009
any idea of numbers and when they may be available from for the new G4 Defender ?- I would be keen to change in my G4 LE defender for a new shape G4 defender.
|
By neo - 19 Jan 2009
FWIW/IMHO,Whilst LR might be counting on the fact that the 'dedicated followers' will be keen to collect, the rest of the market is flat. Add in no service history etc or any event history and the seem even less desireable, unless your are a enthusiast. I understand they have well over 100 cars to deal with, will be interesting to see what happens, I can't see market value being high at present, its not like LR isn't already in a stock pile situation. And, model refresh is due late 2009 including new engines.......
|
By vaqueiro - 20 Jan 2009
Hi folks, Despite being new to this, I'll throw in my opinion. I'm not so sure that a vehicle with no challenge history will appeal to true enthusiasts. This will no doubt reduce it's potential as a collectable vehicle. It should certainly be classed as a limited edition. I guess the '09 vehicles would be of more interest to the wealthy, outdoors type who would see it as a fashion accessory more than anything else. In that respect I don't think that engine type or model will make any difference. However, it would be good to see them on the road even if only to promote the G4 challenge and (with a few stickers) make the public aware of the connection with the IRC&RC societies. As for the colour scheme (no offence to the person(s) responsible for decorating the vehicles) but those side stripes just make me think Motorway Maintenance :D Vaqueiro.
|